Falling Through Darkness by Carolyn MacCullough (0-7613-1934-4)
When Aidan moved to the community, he caught the eyes of all the girls, but he chose Ginny out of all of them to pay attention to. She finds it impossible to ignore him, getting drawn in closer and closer. Then he crossed the line, and got them both into a car accident where he was killed and Ginny survived. But can Ginny start telling the truth about the accident and can she herself live with the truth.
This dark book explores the guilt that survivors have to bear and the truth that they have to face. It is a powerful character study of Ginny, drawing readers into the mystery of what happened during the accident. Hard to put down, it will appeal to girls who like stories with tragic accidents but also to those who are looking for a strong female protagonist grappling with real issues.