The Witch’s Child by Arthur Yorinks, illustrated by Jos. A. Smith.
If you are looking for a great creepy Halloween book, this is it! Even better, it isn’t technically a Halloween book, so you could use it anytime you want a good scare.
Rosina is a horrible, mean witch. She was powerful enough to give herself anything she wanted, except a child. One October night, she builds herself a daughter out of straw and leaves and clumps of hair. But she cannot bring her Rosalie to life. She tries different things to bring Rosalie to life, but nothing works, so she discards her and forgets about her. Then one day, a young girl enters the witch’s house, finds Rosalie, and lavishes her with affection. The witch returns to find this child holding her forgotten daughter and it fills her with rage. But as she moves to attack the girl…
Would I spoil the ending?! Tee hee!
The language and illustrations of this picture book both contribute to the creepy theme. Yorinks has little touches throughout the book that make it all the more shivery. The first page of the book, featuring the witch flying toward the reader without a broomstick, just flying, is paired with some very atmospheric writing that will have children clutching each other when you read it aloud. The witch turns children into thorny bushes, a horrible fate, but then Yorinks adds that they are “stunted and prickly and rooted to the ground.” The witch grabbing a “long knife” to attack the girl is wonderful, as is the pacing of that section where each beat brings the tension up a notch. Whew! And the illustrations are right there too, increasing the tension, adding to the horror, creating a witch without a broomstick or pointed hat that is all the more horrible for missing those details. There is nothing cartoonlike or comforting about this witch.
Recommended for reading aloud at Halloween parties in classrooms for grades 2-4. Children as young as 5 will enjoy the story, but the nuances will be appreciated by slightly older children who want a good thrill with their Halloween goodies.