Hurrah for Adele Geras, who writes the article, “The literary universe is bigger in the blogosphere.” This part is a real gem:
“But why should we believe the blogger?” comes the cry. “Who are they
and how are they qualified to tell us what to read?” The answer is: you
should believe them and trust them in exactly the same way you would a
critic in a newspaper or literary journal. There will be some you
admire and some you think are stupid. Some bloggers write well and some
badly and so do some literary critics.
That’s right! We blog reviewers can be trusted just as much as print reviewers, in fact many of us are print reviewers too. And bloggers just like print reviewers have varying tastes to take into account. There are reviewers (both print and online) who I listen to no matter what. There are others that I read, but with a large salt shaker at hand.
Philip Pullman has won the Carnegie of Carnegies where people had the chance to vote for their favorite Carnegie winner. This was done in celebration of the 70th anniversary of the Carnegie Awards. Pullman’s Northern Lights (known in the US as The Golden Compass) got 40% of the total votes.
Here are the titles that were in contention:
Skellig by David Almond (1998)
Junk by Melvin Burgess (1996)
Storm by Kevin Crossley-Holland (1985)
A Gathering Light by Jennifer Donnelly (2003)
The Owl Service by Alan Garner (1967)
The Family From One End Street by Eve Garnett (1937)
The Borrowers by Mary Norton (1952)
Tom’s Midnight Garden Philiby ppa Pearce (1958)
Northern Lights by Philip Pullman (1995)
Elissa’s Quest by Erica Verrillo.
Elissa is a thirteen-year-old who has lived with her Nana in a small village. She doesn’t know anything about her parents and Nana refuses to tell her anything. Elissa has a gift of talking with animals, and one of her best friends is Gertrude, a donkey. Then one fateful day, Elissa’s father, a royal prince, comes and takes her away. They travel to the Khan’s fortress, where Elissa is to be used as a bargaining chip between the Khan and her father. It is only through her own gifts and newfound courage that Elissa finds her way free of the web she is trapped in. This is the first book in a new series.
Yes, I know the paragraph above is short on details, but one of the joys of this novel is slowly discovering its twists and turns. Elissa is a well-drawn protagonist, a girl who would never think she was brave but finds it deep within herself. Her young companion, Maya, is also charmingly rendered. The adult characters are not as fully imagined as the child characters, but young readers shouldn’t mind that. There is a strong sense of mysticism in the novel, creating a deeper experience than many fantasy novels for youth.
This is the perfect book for tweens. With a protagonist who’s a teenager, tweens should really enjoy reading this. Yet it doesn’t have the sexuality or dark violence of a fully teen novel.
Share this book with tweens who enjoy Tamora Pierce. This is a new female warrior of a different type that they will enjoy rooting for.
This Is a Poem that Heals Fish by Jean-Pierre Simeon, illustrated by Olivier Tallec.
Arthur’s fish is not looking well, in fact Arthur is quite worried that the fish could die of boredom. His mother suggests giving the fish a poem. First, Arthur searches the house for a poem and doesn’t find anything. Then he heads out into the community to ask people what a poem is. He gets answers like this one from the lady who works in the bakery: “it is hot like fresh bread. When you eat it, a little is always left over.” But even with this advice, he really doesn’t understand what a poem is until he is forced to try to revive his fish all on his own. And the fish has a poem for him too.
This rather strange picture book doesn’t hit its stride until page 14. The beginning sets the stage, but also has a rather odd part where noodles and a rag talk. Anyway, once the story gets moving, it is lovely. I truly enjoyed the different definitions of what a poem is and how they all weave together into Arthur’s. The illustrations are filled with deep colors and interesting perspectives. They suit the story perfectly.
This is a great book to use when working with children and poems. It will give children the confidence to create their own poetry and to find it in their own worlds. What more could you ask for?