Sigh. The Washington Post has quite a bitter article about Harry Potter and adults reading children’s fiction. Here are some of the worst of Ron Charles’ piece:
Speaking of adults reading Harry Potter, he says, “I’d like to think that this is a romantic return to youth, but it looks like a bad case of cultural infantilism.”
He does go on to talk about the fact that over half of the adults in the US don’t read any books at all, but why the venom about reading children’s books? It seems to me, as an adult who enjoyed children’s literature, that it offers not a simplified and infantile look at the world, but a purity of language, clarity of voice and a vision that relies on good storytelling rather than violence and sexuality to sell itself to readers.
He goes on to write about the fact that Harry Potter has not created more young readers after all: “Unfortunately, the evidence doesn’t encourage much optimism. Data from
the NEA point to a dramatic and accelerating decline in the number of
young people reading fiction. Despite their enthusiasm for books in
grade school, by high school, most kids are not reading for pleasure at
all.”
But isn’t the question WHY?! Why aren’t adults reading? Why aren’t teens reading? I think it is simplistic to place all of the blame on the Internet, where frankly there is a lot of reading happening. Could it be that they can’t find books that they enjoy? Isn’t that where librarians should step in and recommend great reads that suit that particular reader? One of my favorite things to do is to connect the right person with the right book and watch the magic happen. I love people who are able to voice their likes, and especially their dislikes. So many people though see not only reading but intellectualism as something foreign and offputting. Where do we go from here? How do we inspire reading? How do we make it hip?
These are questions that keep librarians like me up at night. How do I encourage people to take a risk on a new author? To invest the time and energy even with it being free of actual cost? How do we offer access to that Long Tail of libraries where the Harry Potter books bring them in the door but we are ready and waiting with other books they will enjoy?
Let us not despair yet! We still do have readers in this country. We will inspire more. And we can do it with great books, whether classics or new releases, for children or adults.