The Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators (SCBWI) has announced the winners of their Golden Kite Awards and the Sid Fleischman Award. These awards are unique because they are the only ones judged by a jury of author and illustrator peers. Here are the winners in each category as well as the honor books:
Revolution by Deborah Wiles
The Family Romanov by Candace Fleming
PICTURE BOOK ILLUSTRATION WINNER
The Right Word: Roget and His Thesaurus illustrated by Melissa Sweet, written by Jen Bryant
PICTURE BOOK TEXT WINNER
A Dance Like Starlight: One Ballerina’s Dream by Kristy Dempsey, illustrated by Floyd Cooper
Dory Fantasmagory by Abby Hanlon
Freedom Summer: The 1964 Struggle for Civil Rights in Mississippi by Susan Goldman Rubin
PICTURE BOOK ILLUSTRATION HONOR
The Farmer and the Clown by Marla Frazee
PICTURE BOOK TEXT HONOR
The Baby Tree by Sophie Blackall
SID FLEISCHMAN AWARD FOR HUMOR
Evil Librarian by Michelle Knudsen
Red Butterfly by A. L. Sonnichsen
Kara was abandoned as an infant and taken in by an American woman living in China. Her Mama never leaves the apartment they share and Kara doesn’t attend school. Kara does get to leave the apartment each day to run errands on her bicycle, her favorite time of day. In China where the one-child limit is in effect, parents leave infants who have physical challenges like Kara who was born with one hand with only two small fingers on it. Mama longs to return to the United States, but she can’t without abandoning Kara, who has no identification papers and has not been formally adopted. When Mama’s American daughter comes to visit, Kara finds their entire lives turned upside down and their secret exposed. Will Kara be able to bring their family back together again?
Told in lovely rich verse, this novel is elegantly written and conceived. It shows the results of the one-child policy in China and the children who were abandoned because of it. Yet it is far from a condemnation of China or the United States. It is a portrait in contrasts and complexity, showing that there is good and bad in both systems. It is also the story of one very strong young girl who has already lost one family and is determined not to lose another.
Kara is the voice of the book with the poems told from her point of view. She is unique in many ways, including being able to speak English better than she Chinese due to her upbringing. Kara’s disability is handled in a matter-of-fact way for the reader. While she is profoundly ashamed of it, her hand and disability do not label her at all in the novel. Kara’s situation is complicated by the politics of adoption and identity. In her journey to a resolution of where she will live, there are episodes in an orphanage and then later in a home in the United States. These are all deftly and clearly drawn, showing both the universal nature of family and love but also the differences in cultures.
Radiant verse and a very strong young protagonist make this verse novel a treat to read. The unusual subject matter of an older orphan from China makes it a unique read. Appropriate for ages 9-12.
Reviewed from copy received from Simon & Schuster Books.