The Lucy Variations by Sara Zarr
Lucy Beck-Moreau was considered one of the top concert pianists. Now at age 16, she has abruptly left the concert circuit and doesn’t play the piano at all. Instead she is attending school just like any other teenager, doing homework, and listening to her younger brother Gus practice his piano pieces. When Gus’ aging piano teacher dies, she is replaced by Will, a young teacher who was once himself a child pianist and recommends plenty of time away from the piano for Gus, including once forbidden video games and TV. As Will balances out Gus’ life, Lucy is drawn to him. Will is older and sophisticated and interested in Lucy herself as both a pianist and a person. This is the story of Lucy’s triumph over grief and loss and her struggle to play music on her own terms and for her own reasons.
Zarr has beautifully captured a family of wealth and talent without lingering overlong on those details. It is Lucy who is the center of the novel, which is told in third person but specifically from Lucy’s view. This gives the book a necessary distance so that readers can view Lucy from a small space and recognize the mistakes that she is making and repeating. Lucy is a wonder of a flawed protagonist, filled with talent yet drawn into destructive situations of her own making, one feels an affinity to her and yet pushed away as well.
It is this strength of the central character that lifts this novel above others covering similar subjects. The writing here is strong and clear, and the story flows with a natural feel that allows Lucy to veer dangerously close to disasters that make the reading that much more exciting. Along the way, a dysfunctional family is on display, showing readers how Lucy came to be the way that she is, and also showing hope for what is possible.
A true mix of hope, music and tenacity, this book is beautifully composed and harmonious with lingering crescendos. Appropriate for ages 14-17.
Reviewed from library copy.