Carnivores by Aaron Reynolds, illustrated by Dan Santat
It’s hard to be a carnivore when all of the prey whispers behind your back, nobody understands the way you eat, and you are accused of sneaking around. So a lion, a great white shark and a wolf get together to form a support group. Their first plan is to become vegetarians, but that doesn’t go well at all. In fact, the wolf can’t seem to find a berry bush that doesn’t have a bunny in it. The next plan is using disguises to blend in, but one smell of the lion’s zebra breath turns the antelope against him. Finally, the lion asked the great horned owl to speak with them. The owl talked about accepting themselves as carnivores. The others realize that he is right and follow his advice perfectly.
Reynolds has written a book that is screamingly funny. Each page has laughter on it with the perfect timing of his jokes. It begs to be shared aloud with punch lines that just have to be delivered. Happily, the humor is edgy and truly funny, not just for small children. With clever twists throughout the story and situations that make for very funny results, children will be delighted with this look at self-acceptance and meat eating.
Santat’s illustrations are perfection here. Bright colored and bold, just like the humor, they add just the right touch to the book. He manages to capture the comedy perfectly, but not allow his art to blow the punch lines prematurely. The large format will work well with a group, but there are also details that will have to be shared too.
Clever, funny and wonderfully inappropriate, this book asks us all to accept our inner or outer carnivores. Appropriate for ages 4-6, this would also work well as a read-aloud for older elementary kids who will love the humor and the naughtiness of the jokes.
Reviewed from copy received from Chronicle Books.