OK, so I feel like a cantankerous person saying this, but this trailer is not for The Secret Garden. They have introduced elements of fantasy that weren’t in the original book and frankly, I don’t approve. Even Colin Firth can’t distract me from the mess that this looks to be:
What do you think?
I Can Make This Promise by Christine Day (9780062871992)
Released October 1, 2019.
Edie knows that her mother was adopted by a white couple, but the only thing she knows about her mother’s background is that she is Native American. Her mother won’t talk about her childhood at all. While looking in the attic with her friends, Edie discovers a box of old photographs and documents with a woman who looks a lot like her and has the same name! As Edie explores the documents, she realizes that her parents have been lying to her for her entire life. Even when she tries to give them a chance to tell the truth, they continue to avoid it. One of her best friends seems to be more interested in filming Edie’s story than in really supporting her, so Edie must figure out who she can really trust.
This is Day’s debut children’s book and it’s a very special one. Based on her own family history and the government’s role in separating Native children from their families, the book offers a glimpse into the heart wrenching loss of a child. Day also takes on the vital need for Native Americans to be portrayed fully in film, TV and the media.
With those big issues at play, it is to Day’s credit that this story stays firmly focused on Edie and her own journey to understanding her family and her culture. As the mystery of her name and her family is solved, readers will get to experience Edie’s first glimpses of her Native family. The stories are full of deep wounds caused by white government policies that damaged Native families for generations. Still, it is full of hope as well and the promise that healing can continue and justice can be found.
An important book about one Native girl’s journey to learn about her people and herself. Appropriate for ages 9-12.
Reviewed from e-galley provided by HarperCollins.